I recently received an email from someone asking the following question:

“I’ve been reading your blog for a while and a question popped up. What do you think of the practice of ”breaking in” speakers? Is there any truth to it or is it simply just another one of the million myths believed by audiophiles?”

To answer this question, I’ll tell a story.

At work, we have a small collection of loudspeakers – not only current B&O models, but older ones as well. In addition, of course, we have a number of loudspeakers made by our competitors. Many loudspeakers in this collection don’t get used very often, but occasionally, we’ll bring out a pair to have a listen as a refresher or reminder. Usually, the way this works is that one of us from the acoustics department will sneak into the listening room with a pair of loudspeakers, and set them up behind an acoustically transparent, but visually opaque curtain. The rest of us then get together and listen to the same collection of recordings at the same listening level, each of sitting in the same chair. We talk about how things sound, and then we open the curtain to see what we’ve been complaining about.

One day, about three years ago, it was my turn to bring in the loudspeakers, so I set up a pair of passive loudspeakers (not B&O) that have a reasonably good reputation. We had a listen and everyone agreed that the sound was less than optimal (to be polite…). No bass, harsh upper midrange, everything sounded like it was weirdly compressed. Not many of us had anything nice to say. I opened the curtain, and everyone in the room was surprised when they saw what we had listened to – since we would have all expected things to sound much better.

Later that day, I spoke with one of our colleagues who was not in the room, and I told him the story – no one liked the sound, but those speakers should sound better. His advice was to wait until next week, and play the same loudspeakers again – but the next time, play pink noise through them at a reasonably high level for a couple of hours before we listened. So, the next week, the day before we were scheduled to have our listening session, I set up the same speakers in the same locations in the room, and played pink noise at about 70 dB SPL through them overnight. The next morning, we had our blind listening session, and everyone in the room agreed that the sound was quite good – much better than what we heard last week. I opened the curtains and everyone was surprised again to see that nothing had changed. Or had it? I was as surprised as anyone, since my religious belief precludes this story from being true. But I was there… it actually happened.

So, what’s the explanation? Simple! Go to the store and buy two identical pairs of sneakers (or “running shoes” or “trainers”, depending on where you’re from). When you get home, take one pair out of the box, and wear them daily. After three or four months, take the pair that you left in the box and try them on. They will NOT feel the same as the pair you’ve been wearing. This is not a surprise – the leather and plastic and rubber in the sneakers you’ve been wearing has been stretched and flexed and now fits your foot better than the ones you have not been wearing. In addition, you’ll probably notice that the “old” ones are more flexible in the places where your foot bends, because you’ve been bending them.

It turns out (according to the colleague who suggested the pink noise trick who also used to design and make loudspeaker drivers for a living) that the suspension (the surround and spider) of a loudspeaker driver becomes more flexible by repeated flexing – just like your sneakers. If you take a pair of loudspeakers out of the box, plug them in, and start listening, they’ll be stiff. You need to work them a little to “loosen them up”.

This is not only true of new sneakers (and speakers) but also of sneakers (and speakers). For example, I keep my old sneakers around to use when I’m mowing the lawn. When I stick my foot into the sneakers that I haven’t worn all winter, they feel stiff, like a new pair, because they have not been flexed for a while. This is what happened to those speakers that I brought upstairs after sitting in the basement storage for years. The suspensions became stiff and needed to be moved a little before using them for listening to music.

A small problem that compounds the complexity of evaluating this issue is that we also “get used to” how things sound. So, as you’re “breaking in” a loudspeaker by listening to it, you are also learning and accommodating yourself to how it sounds, so you’re both changing simultaneously. Unless you have the option of playing a trick on people like I did with my colleagues, it’s difficult to make a reliable judgement of how big a difference this makes.